Job interviews often end the same way. The hiring manager asks themselves: "Would this person fit in here?" It’s a common practice — 84% of recruiters use "culture fit" as a key hiring factor, according to the Society of Human Resource Management.
But here's the problem with that question: hiring managers are confusing values alignment with personality matching, says Crystina Brooks, a partner at national recruiting agency MICA Consulting Group. "Would I grab a beer with them?" and "Do they make me comfortable?" become unofficial screening criteria. This translates to hiring for social comfort and sameness instead of the skills that actually drive results.
Below, Brooks explains how well-intentioned culture fit hiring sabotages team performance — and what forward-thinking organizations do instead.
3 ways culture fit hiring can backfire
1. It creates echo chambers that kill fresh thinking
The most dangerous part of echo chambers isn’t what teams say, it’s what they never think to question. When everyone shares the same professional background, they make the same assumptions about customers, markets and solutions.
Brooks saw this play out with a startup client that insisted on hiring only candidates from their industry. "We presented diverse candidates with fresh perspectives, but they chose someone who thought exactly like them," she explains. "And when the company tried to expand into new markets, it struggled. No one on the team understood different customer needs or cultural nuances.”
Takeaway: "If a company isn’t thinking about all perspectives, then it can be hard to create, pitch or innovate for people [with varying] needs," Brooks says.
2. It reinforces unconscious bias in disguise
Beyond creating echo chambers, culture fit hiring also provides cover for discrimination. “‘Fit’ often becomes a proxy for ‘comfort’ — gravitating toward those who look, talk or act like us,” Brooks cautions. “This perpetuates bias across gender, race, socioeconomic background and communication style.”
Companies encounter this pitfall even when they try to diversify. At one large consumer products company, leadership requested a woman for a marketing role. Brooks presented qualified candidates of all genders, but the company picked a male candidate as the “best fit.” The hire performed well, but the decision showed how subjective “fit” assessments quietly override diversity intentions.
Takeaway: When you find yourself preferring one candidate for subjective reasons, pause and ask: What specific skills justify this choice? Does this person share our values in action? Will they bring something new that makes us better? These questions help you separate real qualifications from unconscious bias.
3. It discourages healthy conflict
When everyone thinks similarly and prioritizes harmony, nobody wants to challenge flawed ideas. But “[breakthroughs depend] on respectful debate,” stresses Brooks.
She points to a product team that told new hires to “blend in” rather than “rock the boat.” When a junior analyst questioned a pricing model, leadership sidelined them instead of investigating their concerns. Six months later, that model cost the company millions in lost renewals.
Takeaway: “We need people who aren’t afraid of hurting feelings,” Brooks says. “Being respectful is important, but if we don’t ask the hard questions, how can a company progress?” Team members need safe spaces to speak up.
How to build stronger, more innovative teams
“Instead of 'fit,' progressive organizations focus on adding culture, diversity and structured hiring,” says Brooks.
Here’s how:
- Hire for ‘culture add’ instead of ‘culture fit.’ First, define values as behaviors (e.g., collaboration, customer obsession). Then, ask: “What’s missing from our team that this candidate could add? What skillset and behaviors would work well in this team?”
- Use structured interviews. Create two to three behavioral questions for all candidates and grade them with consistent rubrics. For example, you might ask them about a time they disagreed with a team decision, or to describe how they handled a project that wasn’t going as planned. The answers will reveal how candidates actually work, not just how well they interview.
- Separate values from style. Focus on core behaviors, such as integrity and curiosity, rather than personality preferences. "You may want someone to look and be professional, but that can look different for [everyone]," Brooks points out.
This shift requires discipline but pays off. "Organizations that hire based on values while welcoming diverse thinkers often see more innovation, lower turnover and better hiring decisions," Brooks highlights.
What is USA TODAY Top Workplaces 2025?
Do you work for a great company? Each year, USA TODAY Top Workplaces, a collaboration between Energage and USA TODAY, ranks organizations across the United States that excel at creating a positive work environment for their employees. Employee feedback determines the winners.
In 2025, over 1,500 companies earned recognition as top workplaces. Check out our overall U.S. rankings. You can also gain insights into more workplace trends and advice by checking out the links below.
